Skip to content

Rapture No, Apocalypse Yes

May 30, 2011

The world may not have ended last weekend but according to a story I read, life as we know it may well be seriously endangered.

It appears that a girl in Scotland has been granted permission to listen to an iPod while taking her final school exams because she isn’t able to concentrate unless she is listening to music.

The article says that she is in the final year of high school, which would put her in her late teens. 

The key points of the story are:

  • She can’t concentrate unless she’s listening to music so she wants to listen to music while sitting for final exams
  • The school said too bad
  • The parents appealed to the examination board
  • The board said too bad
  • So far, so good, other than one wonders about the parents
  • The parents threatened to sue (no need to wonder about the parents any more)
  • The school authorities caved because lawyers warned that they may be guilty of “discrimination” under the Equalities Act because the girl “often struggles to pay attention in class” (apparently that is a disability that you can’t discriminate against)
  • The school authorities are “bracing for a flood of similar claims”
  • The iPod has to be loaded by the examination staff to make sure it doesn’t have anything that might give her an advantage on the exams–but the songs on it must be the ones she wants to listen to
  • The exam staff are angry because they now have additional work in the form of loading the iPod
  • School authorities are worried about how they are going to get the staff to load up additional iPods when the “flood of similar claims” (which will clearly all have merit) starts

I don’t know about you, but I’m very confused.  My dictionary defines concentration as “to bring or direct toward a common center or objective; to direct attention to a single object; focus.  The girl has trouble doing this.  As the article says, she “often struggles to pay attention in class.” 

Well I’m a bit of an expert on this topic.  Because just about every teacher I ever had (and a few bosses) said that about me at one time or another.  And in my capacity as an expert, I can tell you that sensory bombardment (i.e., music delivered via earphones) does not aid and abet “directing attention to a single object,” in this case the test questions. 

I remember a math teacher telling me that my attempt to simultaneously listen to him and read a comic book was the equivalent of trying to focus on two separate things with each eye.  And it couldn’t be done.   He was right about that—but he was mistaken that I was actually trying to listen to him.

And that might be something for the school authorities (and parents) to think about.  Sitting in class is a passive activity and when you are passive it’s easy for your mind to wander.  But taking an exam requires a modicum of engagement that you would imagine would help one to focus.  Writing your name on the paper involves some degree of focussed attention, if only to manage to get it on the right line.  How come the people responsible for delivering education don’t know that?  After all, by reinforcing this kind of behaviour they have sort of severely limited the number of careers this girl can pursue.  I can’t see her being an airline pilot, lawyer, doctor, beautician, call center attendant, check out clerk, waitress, cop, teacher, actress, singer.  Do I need to go on?  She probably can’t get any job because she has to wear her iPod in order to concentrate and one assumes she would need to concentrate at a job interview. 

Forgive me for sounding politically incorrect, but this girl doesn’t have a disability.  If anything, she is a victim—of her parents’ laziness and the cowardice of the school authorities.  I am all for making allowances and accommodating students who have a genuine disability, but it’s worrisome when some people consider themselves victims if they are inconvenienced when asked to conform with basic norms of human behaviour.  And it’s even more unfortunate when people in leadership positions won’t make tough decisions because they are afraid of a lawsuit.

If I were running that school, I’d say, “So sue me.” And if the parents did, I’d limit my legal costs to taking out a full page ad in the local paper explaining the suit and listing all the school programs that will have to be cut because of legal expenses or reallocation of resources from normal teaching to loading iPods, etc.  I bet that (a) I’d get a lot of contributions to my legal fund and (b) the suit might well go away. 

In retrospect, I’m kind of happy that my math teacher confiscated my comic book.  Not because I learned any math, but because I learned about priorities and self discipline and, again in retrospect, that has been a very good thing.

The girl has probably never heard her parents say the word “no.”  Or if she has, she has learned that they are only too happy to take the easy way out and oblige her every demand.  It may be unfair of me to make rash assumptions, but I bet that this girl has pretty much iTuned out of the world for a while.  She is no different that the scores of teenagers I’ve seen sitting in restaurants with their parents, earphones stuck in their ears and looks of cosmic pain on their faces at being forced to interact in some small way with the real world.   I can understand the parents being perfectly happy to have the kid quiet and tractable and iSedated all the time, but then what’s the point of having kids?

24 Comments leave one →
  1. May 30, 2011 3:22 pm

    Well, I have always wondered what the point of having kids could possibly be. You could get better results by acquiring a small dog and setting fire to your money while the dog pees on the carpet, meanwhile hitting yourself on the head and letting a troop of monkeys pull your hair.

    Harlan Ellison once said he couldn’t write without rock and roll cranked up to the max in his workroom, and his output was not too shabby, but I don’t get that, either.

    • June 3, 2011 5:14 am

      Love the first paragraph of your comment, sledpress…brilliant!

      My man goes to sleep every night with earphones streaming old TV programs into his head…I think it’s an ADHD thing…

      Mom/stepmom of five, Gramma of one (who makes it worth having the kids to get the grandkid!)

      • June 3, 2011 9:05 pm

        I love it too, but didn’t want to be the first person to say so!

        • June 4, 2011 12:18 am

          I knew that if I waited long enough I would find people who loved me for being grouchy.

  2. May 30, 2011 4:53 pm

    Unbelievable…I’m glad that I am no longer teaching and having to put up with yet another absurb request or requirement. I am in favor of providing the necessary accomodations for students who are truly in need but this is way over the top. I agree with you, the parents are not accustomed to telling their daughter “no!”

    I would have no such problem at our home. Already working on the next generation since my children are grown. Grandson Jack definitely is learning the meaing of “No”.

  3. Len Skuta permalink
    May 31, 2011 2:53 am

    How sad. When I went to school there were rules and they were meant .
    to be followed.

  4. May 31, 2011 3:30 am

    This is the monster we’ve created. The decision makers are likely part of the generation that think this all makes sense. The called us the “me” generation in the 60s. What are the kids today, “more about me than you could ever imagine” generation.

  5. May 31, 2011 11:48 am

    Love the argument differentiating between passive listening in class and actively taking a test. Makes all the sense in the world, as opposed to her parents handling of the situation

  6. Dug permalink
    May 31, 2011 11:58 am

    Heartily agree with all the above “shame”…
    Do hope though, that you got your “Comic Book” returned in good shape….

  7. May 31, 2011 2:31 pm

    What’s going to happen to the girl once she’s out of school and on her own and discovers she’s nothing special, that no one’s going to bend over backyard to make her happy? Poor thing.

  8. June 1, 2011 1:09 am

    Wow. That was a good one! Poor child, probably should have been a Music Appreciation major. She may be limited in her career choices with such a disability, but could be just right for the CIA, listening in on people who have been wire tapped.

  9. June 1, 2011 5:56 am

    Some people can’t concentrate in quiet spaces. They need external sound to drown out their inner clamor. Some people can’t sleep when it’s “too quiet,” and some sleep with the lights on because they had a bad childhood experience in the dark.

    When I was still dabbling in acting, I found public places, such as cafes and bars, the best places to study lines. For some reason, the commotion and noise level around me improved my ability to concentrate. The mind works in mysterious ways sometimes.

    Regarding tests, the only thing that broke my concentration was whispering going on around me as opposed to talking at a normal level. I wanted either silence, or regular sound, not the artificially suppressed kind designed to cause less of a disturbance to my concentration.

  10. June 1, 2011 11:50 am

    I hope the staff exact their revenge by sneaking in something she won’t like. How about Stravinsky’s “Rite of Spring” or something by an atonal composer?

  11. Snoring Dog Studio permalink
    June 2, 2011 12:09 am

    I don’t understand why earplugs or something similar might not have worked. It’s possible the girl does have a sensory deficit, which I would hope the parents would have investigated, rather than going to this extreme.

  12. June 3, 2011 8:45 am

    I need absolute quiet when I write. I work in an open plan office where music is often playing (we are creatives!) and it does my head in. That being said, when I was a teen I always studied with music on. I even sang along while I did my homework.
    Could explain a lot….

    • June 3, 2011 9:03 pm

      I can tolerate music as long as it’s my music and not someone else’s. I usually have something on when I’m working but don’t really hear it.

  13. June 4, 2011 7:14 pm

    In retrospect, I appear to have been disabled in my youth. I am going to go somewhere quiet and feel bad about it, and then I’m going to lawyer up.

  14. June 5, 2011 5:18 am

    Hi Thomas, Congratulations! You have been awarded The Versatile Blogger Award. Stop by at for more details.

  15. June 5, 2011 2:45 pm

    “Forgive me for sounding politically incorrect, but this girl doesn’t have a disability. If anything, she is a victim—of her parents’ laziness and the cowardice of the school authorities. ”

    She was a victim long before just by being able to get to that point. And more and more we are all becomming victims of a litigious, me-first society.

  16. June 6, 2011 8:32 am

    When I went to school aeons ago, the teacher’s words were law and the rules made by the school authorities were not to be disputed. And our parents did not pander to us as these parents obviously do. Anything for a quiet life seems to be the motto here.
    And are there siblings? Imagine living in that house.
    As you know Thomas, here in NZ we have really gone over the top with our political correctness and have to be really, really careful not to upset anybody. This poor, disadvantaged child who obviously has everything that she can possibly ask her parents for, has now come up against authority and won. Where will it end.
    If, when she is driving the car that daddy bought her (and in the UK you can drive at 17) she is stopped for speeding or some other infringement, will she be able to appeal to the court that she could only concentrate on driving with loud music in her ears and going at high speed?
    This child’s future is sure messed up.
    Thanks for sharing – I missed this article in the media.
    And thanks for subscribing to my blog.
    Judith 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: